Evidence boundary: Official information is separated from community testing. Values that may have changed are dated, and unresolved claims are marked Pending confirmation.
What the sources verify
MrGuider ranks Astral Rastrar and Sky Flare in weapon S tier, with Ghost Crystal, Ghost Face, Ghost Hand, World Ender, and Kiss of Death in A tier. Its role-based race list places Lucifer in S for damage, durability, and agility, while Night Elf and Lucifer are S for farming. Gamezebo’s weapon list also places Sky Flare in S, making it the strongest direct agreement between the two collected lists.
How to use this information
Choose a ranking dimension first: boss damage, farming speed, durability, agility, or material efficiency. Compare your actual forged multiplier and substats before replacing a lower-tier name, because a strong roll can outperform a weak roll from a higher tier. For a new account, favor weapons you can forge repeatedly and control reliably rather than chasing a rare S-tier name immediately.
Version notes and pending confirmation
Cinder Breaker and Hellforged Blade sit high on Gamezebo but lower on MrGuider, showing a direct version or methodology conflict. Crown Claw and Dragon Dual Blade also receive conflicting recommendations, so their current placement is Pending confirmation. No public official source validates any S-to-D ranking, and balance patches can invalidate both lists.
Frequently asked questions
What is the safest S-tier pick?+
Sky Flare has the clearest cross-source agreement. Availability and your forged roll still matter.
Is an S-tier race always best?+
No. The ranking changes by damage, farming, durability, and agility, and race stars change bonuses.
Sources checked
Source access and game balance can change after the research date.